Consultation response

11 September 2015

FEE comments on the IESBA Exposure Draft: “Responding to Non-Compliance with Laws and Regulations”

The ED is a significant improvement from the former ED on Responding to a Suspected Illegal Act. It has gone some way to finding a good balance between responding to stakeholders’ expectations and complying with the applicable legal framework.

FEE agrees with IESBA that the Code is not meant to override national law, and should be applied without prejudice to any applicable legal provisions. In FEE’s view, this is an essential clarification that ought to be more prominent in the finalised Code.  

FEE has consistently supported the concept of transparency in its public policy work while recognising limits and practical difficulties that could arise when applying this concept. FEE had previously expressed the opinion that IESBA should not seek to require disclosure in the absence of an appropriate legal framework and retains this stance. FEE is therefore pleased that mandatory reporting is no longer being considered, as this would have resulted in unintended and adverse consequences, potentially reducing the ability of PAs to influence potential non-compliance. FEE would also welcome that the Code clarify that disclosure is precluded where there is a conflict with local laws and regulations, an example being tipping-off concerns under anti-money laundering legislation where a discussion with management may not always be lawfully allowed.  


Related files:

 FEE comment letter to IESBA on the Exposure Draft: “Responding to Non-Compliance with Laws and Regulations”

Related links:

 IESBA Exposure Draft “Responding to Non-Compliance with Laws and Regulations”

Related content

BlogAccountants and ethics: promoting trust in the public sector

8 September 2022

Consultation responseIESBA’s survey on its future strategy and workplan

6 July 2022

Consultation responseIESBA’s proposed revisions to the Code on engagement team and group audits definition

31 May 2022

Consultation responseIAASB’s survey consultation: work plan for 2022‒2023

25 August 2021

Consultation responseIESBA’s proposed revisions to the definitions of listed entity and public interest entity in the...

5 May 2021

Podcast Ethics, digitalisation and accounting

16 December 2020

Consultation responseIESBA’s proposed revisions to the fee-related provisions of the code

10 June 2020

Consultation responseIESBA’s proposed revisions to the non-assurance services provisions of the code

10 June 2020

Consultation responseIESBA’s exposure draft on proposed revision to the code addressing the objectivity of engagement quality...

7 April 2020

Consultation responseIESBA Exposure Draft on Proposed Revisions to the Code to Promote the Role and Mindset

4 November 2019

Team memberHarun Saki

22 July 2019

Consultation responseIESBA’s consultation paper on professional skepticism – meeting public expectations

15 August 2018

Consultation responseIESBA’s Proposed Strategy and Work Plan 2019 – 2023

16 July 2018

Consultation responseIESBA’s fees questionnaire

1 March 2018

Consultation responseIESBA’s Exposure Draft proposed revisions to the Code pertaining to the offering and accepting of...

8 December 2017

Consultation responseIESBA Strategy Survey April 2017

1 August 2017

Consultation responseIESBA Proposed Application Material Relating to Professional Skepticism and Professional Judgment

14 July 2017

Consultation responseIESBA Exposure Draft Improving the Structure of the Code of Ethics for Professional Accountants –...

24 May 2017

Consultation responseProposed Revisions to Clarify the Applicability of Provisions in Part C of the Extant Code...

24 April 2017

Consultation responseProposed Revisions Pertaining to Safeguards in the Code – Phase 2 and Related Conforming Amendments

24 April 2017

Sign up for our newsletter

* indicates required
Would you like to subscribe to our newsletter?
On which topics would you like to receive news?