News

2 February 2022

Stronger corporate reporting in Europe – solutions by the accountancy profession Statement

Accountancy Europe commends the European Commission (EC) for its initiative and for adopting a holistic approach to the 3 pillars of corporate reporting: corporate governance & reporting, statutory audit, and their supervision. Our profession is open-minded to change and ready to contribute to the EC’s efforts to enhance the corporate reporting ecosystem. We propose several solutions below, and in more detail in our consultation response.

We concur with the EC’s objective to strengthen each pillar, so the ecosystem is better equipped to deal with company failures and minimise their occurrence. The overall framework should become more coherent, ensuring the 3 pillars are complementary and systemically effective in the EU.

Any measure taken should aim at providing reliable and timely information to shareholders, investors, and other stakeholders.

The EC’s focus on integrating financial and sustainability reporting is paramount. This, supported by the auditor’s involvement in both, provides a more accurate picture of a company.

We support developing quality indicators for corporate reporting, statutory audit, and supervision on a multi-stakeholder basis.

Corporate Governance and reporting

Robust corporate governance and reporting should underpin enhancing the auditor’s role in internal controls (including on fraud and going concern) and more informative audit reports. Companies should issue a public statement on the effectiveness of internal controls over financial reporting, focusing on fraud and going concern.

All public interest entities (PIEs) should have a separate audit committee and there should be no Member State options on this requirement. The audit committee should have enough members competent in accounting and auditing. In large PIEs, an independent internal audit function and well-established whistleblowing structures should support the audit committee.

Audit

We would welcome further simplification and harmonisation of the audit rules across Europe, including removing Member State options, for example on prohibited non-audit services.

EU legislation and ethical rules already firmly restrict auditors from providing non-audit services to PIE audit clients. To meet stakeholders’ expectations and emerging needs, auditors should continue being allowed to provide services closely linked to financial statements audit and assurance services, for example assurance on sustainability information, to their audit clients.

We welcome the EC looking into ways to increase choice and capacity in the PIE audit market. Substantively changing the market structure will take time, as mid-tier audit firms will need to continue investing in the required expertise and capacity to undertake PIE audits. Further evidence is needed on how any potential market opening measure, such as joint audit, would impact audit quality.

Supervision of Reporting and audit

There is merit in harmonising reporting and audit supervisors’ policies and activities to achieve a level playing field embedded in EU legislation.

We support robust supervision and enhanced regulators at EU and national level. Any new powers would need to be proportionate, with adequate checks and balances.

We believe that supervisors’ work should be more transparent, for example by publishing their inspection reports on individual PIE audit firms.

The supervisory framework should build an environment that fosters learning and development for both companies and auditors, rather than focus on sanctioning.

Related content

NewsEU reaches agreement on the CSRD: a historic moment for corporate reporting

30 June 2022

PublicationPublic audit oversight

29 June 2022

PublicationDefining a public interest entity

21 June 2022

EventESG & Corporate Governance: the evolving role of audit committees

20 June 2022

PublicationStronger internal controls to reduce corporate risks

17 June 2022

UpdateAudit Policy

7 June 2022

PublicationNon-audit services

30 May 2022

PublicationMandatory rotation of auditors

30 May 2022

Consultation responseEC’s corporate sustainability due diligence proposal

20 May 2022

EventAudit quality: definition, drivers and indicators

18 May 2022

UpdateAudit Policy

12 May 2022

PublicationSustainability assurance under the CSRD

10 May 2022

PublicationAudit Quality Indicators: a global overview of initiatives

5 May 2022

UpdateAudit Policy

13 April 2022

PublicationESG Governance

12 April 2022

EventCSRD: state of play before the final EU negotiations

30 March 2022

UpdateAudit Policy

10 March 2022

NewsWar in Ukraine – responses from the accountancy profession

9 March 2022

NewsEU Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive: a global milestone that will need further clarity

24 February 2022

NewsExecutive directors’ bonuses must be linked with sustainability objectives

16 February 2022

Sign up for our newsletter

* indicates required
Would you like to subscribe to our newsletter?
On which topics would you like to receive news?